sportsbook betting odds

SPORTSBOOK BETTING ODDS: WHY UNDERDOGS ARE A WORSE BET THAN THEY LOOK

Higher sportsbook betting odds are tempting, but bigger payouts don't always mean better value. Learn why favorites may offer the smarter long-term bet.

AWAlex Williams4 min read10 Oct 2026Updated 11 Oct 2026

Betting on favorites tends to lose bettors a small amount over the long run, somewhere around 1 to 2 percent of what they stake. Betting on longshots loses far more, often north of 10 percent, sometimes deeper than that. That gap isn't random. It's one of the most studied patterns in sports betting research, and it shows up directly in how sportsbook betting odds get priced on Arena365 casino and everywhere else.

What's Actually Going On Here

Economists call it the favorite-longshot bias. Across decades of data, from horse racing to football to cricket, the same pattern holds: bettors as a group put more money on underdogs than the true probability justifies, and less on favorites than their real chances deserve. Favorite odds tend to reflect something close to fair value, while longshot odds run worse, sometimes considerably worse. It's a pattern worth understanding before you read sportsbook betting odds on Arena365 as a straightforward measure of what "should" happen.

This isn't a fringe theory. It's documented in peer-reviewed research covering multiple sports, including studies that specifically examined cricket betting alongside football, boxing, and college sports in the US. The bias holds up across bookmakers, eras, and countries.

Why Bettors Keep Doing It Anyway

Nobody sits down planning to lose more money. A big payout on a long-odds underdog is exciting in a way a modest return on a heavy favorite isn't, and that excitement pulls stakes toward outcomes people would rate as unlikely if asked directly. There's also a plain misjudgment of probability at play. Most people struggle to intuitively separate a 20 percent chance from a 5 percent chance. Both feel like "it could happen," even though one is four times more likely than the other.

Sportsbook betting odds on Arena365 casino price in exactly this dynamic. When more money chases a longshot than its real probability supports, the price doesn't need to move to reflect actual risk, it just needs to cover what the platform expects to pay out relative to what's being staked.

How This Shows Up In Decimal Odds Specifically

On Arena365, odds are shown in decimal format, where the number is your total return per unit staked. A heavy favorite might sit around 1.30 to 1.40. An underdog in the same match might carry odds of 4.00 or higher. The favorite-longshot bias means that high number is usually less generous than it looks relative to the actual chance of that outcome happening, while the low number on the favorite is often closer to a fair reflection of the real odds.

Put a rough number on it. If a true probability is 20 percent, fair decimal odds would sit at 5.00. Under the favorite-longshot bias, the actual price often lands lower, maybe 4.20 or 4.40, because so much betting activity is already chasing that outcome. The favorite on the other side, priced closer to its real probability, ends up the better-value bet even though the payout looks smaller.

That doesn't mean underdogs never win, or that betting on one is always a mistake. It means the math works against a betting pattern of consistently chasing longshots for the bigger payout, more so than most bettors realize when they're just scanning sportsbook betting odds and picking whichever number looks exciting.

What This Actually Means For How You Bet

None of this is an argument for only ever backing favorites. Occasional underdog bets, placed because you genuinely think the platform has mispriced something, are a different activity from habitually chasing the biggest number on the board. The distinction is intent. Betting an underdog because you've spotted a specific reason the price looks wrong is a judgment call. Betting an underdog every time simply because the payout is bigger is the exact pattern the research describes, and it's the one that tends to lose money over time.

Arena365 casino displays every price the same way regardless of which side of this bias it falls on, so the responsibility sits with the bettor to recognize the pattern rather than assume every listed number is equally fair.

Where Most Of The Confusion Sits

A few things worth clearing up about how sportsbook betting odds on Arena365 actually behave:

  • Longshot odds and favorite odds are equally fair, just different payout sizes. They're not. Research consistently shows longshot odds run worse relative to true probability than favorite odds do.

  • A big payout means a bookmaker sees real value in that outcome. It usually means the opposite, that heavy public demand for the longshot let the price drift away from fair value.

  • This bias only applies to horse racing. It doesn't. Studies have found it across football, cricket, boxing, and college sports, not just racing markets.

  • Understanding this bias means you should never bet on underdogs. It doesn't mean that. It means treating a big number as automatically good value is the actual mistake, not betting on an underdog itself.

18+. Play responsibly. Arena365 is licensed by the Anjouan Gaming Authority. For support, contact [email protected].

#sportsbook betting odds

Frequently asked questions

It's a well-documented pattern where bettors overvalue underdogs relative to their real chances of winning, and undervalue favorites, causing longshot odds to run worse value than favorite odds over the long run.

Yes. Academic research covering multiple sports, including cricket matches, has found the same pattern: underdog prices tend to be less favorable relative to true probability than favorite prices.

No. Favorites lose regularly. The bias is about value relative to true probability across many bets, not a guarantee about any single match.

The prospect of a large payout pulls more betting activity toward underdogs than their actual win probability supports, which is exactly the behavior researchers point to as the cause of the bias.

Open arena365.com on any phone or desktop browser, no app or APK needed. Log in with your phone number and a 4-digit SMS code, then go to Sports or Live Betting.

About the author

AW
iGaming & Casino Specialist

Expertise · Online Casino, Slots & Gambling Insights

Alex is an iGaming specialist focused on online casinos, slot games, and digital gambling experiences. He covers casino reviews, game mechanics, bonuses, payment methods, and player-focused insights. With extensive knowledge of the online casino industry, Alex creates informative content designed to help players understand casino features, promotions, and responsible gambling practices.

Keep reading

Related guides & analysis

Masterclass

Nicholas Pooran Masterclass series

Inside the mindset, preparation and strategy behind T20 cricket.

Fresh off the desk

Latest articles